Home All Vintage Old Mission Recipes: Lucile Lindsey’s Cinnamon Rolls

Vintage Old Mission Recipes: Lucile Lindsey’s Cinnamon Rolls

6
Donate to Old Mission Gazette

Mrs. Lindsey’s Cinnamon Rolls have reached epic status for anyone who grew up on the Old Mission Peninsula and attended Old Mission Peninsula Elementary School (OMPS). Mrs. Lindsey, along with Jo Brown, Clarissa Boursaw and others, were cooks at the school, and back then, all the food was home-made right there.

Including Mrs. Lindsey’s Cinnamon Rolls. Her daughter Helen Mumford gave me the recipe in 1998, and while my rolls might not have the same magical love as Mrs. Lindsey’s, they take me back to a simpler time and hold a lot of nostalgia for me.

Help Support Old Mission Gazette - Click Here

Do you have a favorite memory of Mrs. Lindsey’s cooking or OMPS food? Leave thoughts in the comments below.

Lucile Lindsey’s Cinnamon Rolls or Bread

Place 1 quart warm water with 2 Tbsp. salt in mixer. Add and mix:

For Cinnamon Rolls:

3/4 c. sugar

2/3 c. shortening

For Bread:

1/3 c. sugar

1/3 c. shortening

After mixing, sprinkle 3 packages of dry yeast over top and let stand 5 min. or until dissolved.

Mix 1 c. cornmeal, 1/2 c. dry milk, and 3 c. flour together, then add to liquid and keep adding flour until you can mix by hand.

Turn out on board and kneed a little. Place in ball, cover and let rise 1/2 hour to 1 hour. Divide into 3 equal parts.

For Bread: Place in pans and let rise until half again the size.

For Rolls: Roll out, spread with melted butter, cinnamon and sugar. Roll up, slice and place in pan. (Place melted butter with Karo Syrup in bottom of pan if candy bottom is desired).

For bread: Bake 350 for 40 min.

For cinnamon rolls: Bake 375 for 25 min.

Makes 3 loaves or 3 dozen cinnamon rolls.

We need your support...

At a time when newspapers across the country are dying in droves, small community newspapers like Old Mission Gazette are the wave of the future. Owners Tim and Jane Boursaw are devoted to the Old Mission Peninsula community, and our editorial independence means we set our own agenda and voice our own opinions. But we need your ongoing support to keep delivering Old Mission Peninsula news, history, photos and more. We rely on generous reader support to keep doing what we do, and every contribution, big or small, is valuable. Click HERE to support Old Mission Gazette. Thank you!


Bay View Insurance of Traverse City Michigan

6 COMMENTS

  1. I remember those…and her cherry pies among other things. Most of all I remember Lucile’s kind loving heart and her openness and warmth. Thanks for the reminder of my wonderful time on Old Mission.

    • Thanks for the note, Rick. She really was the epitome of a kind and loving person. And the Bible studies that I went to (as a teenager!) at Bob and Lucile’s really set me on a path to always keep God in my life. I wish I could sit at their table for just one more Bible study (but that day will come). 🙂

  2. Before OMPS opened, I used to spend time with Mrs.Lindsey In The kitchen at the old school that they made in to their house. My older brother, Ralph, would take me to school with him when my Mother needed a babysitter and I would stay downstairs in the kitchen with her. We would make peanut butter and honey sandwiches for lunch and take them upstairs to the class room at lunch time. She was also my 4H leader for sewing. I remember making an apron.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.